Crawling out from under my rock to leave a review. This is my absolute favorite podcast, I love you guys! Hilarious, informative, respectful to the victims. Hope you keep going for years and years to come!

I’ve always been a true crime fanatic. I listen to so many different versions and this by far is one of the best. As the host says at the beginning of the episodes, they are a comedy duo who tell stories about true crime. As someone who probably over consumes true crime, I love that I can turn these guys on and laugh through 80% of the story while still consuming all of the facts about the case. These two may not be everyone’s taste, but they crack me up and I am not one to be easily made to laugh as I don’t find most comedy funny.

You guys crack me up and the research and details are impressive

Judgmental, crass, senseless.

This podcast is funny—but beyond that, the research is top-notch, and they do their own analysis. This isn’t one of those podcasts where they just read Wikipedia aloud. Jimmy & Jimmie are smart & funny. They walk us through the absurdities of every small town and every stupid murderer who thinks, “They’ll never know it was me.”

I listen everyday. Next episode here I go

Love Love Love! I just started over from the beginning for the third time. Every episode is worth the listen!! So good... Live shows rock!! Best

I like Rigatoni.

Perfection

The best podcast ever!!

Erection projection

James and Jimmie are hilarious, I highly recommend!

Awesome funny show love it

It’s a fantastic show, really. Just wished they released more accessible new episodes instead of like 5 locked ones and then one accessible one for the month.

Stories are well-researched and told really well. Hosts have a great banter.

Best podcast around. Listen to it as soon as it drops every week! Check out Your Stupid Opinions as well! It is hilarious! :)

Every single episode makes me laugh

Bingeable

I can’t wait for this Patreon!

I love the way James tells the story! I love the comedy from James and Jimmie!!You will LOVE this podcast! These guys are truly the best!!! They also have “crime in sports”! Even if you don’t watch or follow ANY sport (like me) lol. You WILL love that podcast! “Your stupid opinions” is another hilarious and AMAZING podcast they do!! Give James and Jimmy a chance! I promise, you will NOT be disappointed! If I could give ALL the stars, I would!! 😉 🤣 - If you know, you know!! 🙃😉

Brilliant!

I’m really visual so thank you for the picture of George Washington kicking off his boots to go into the bounce house and then losing his teeth in the corn hole tournament and furthermore losing his wig in the dunk tank. Y’all are amazing. Keep up the good work.

I am very new to this podcast and I’ve started from 2018 on up. I’m still listening. This is an awesome podcast.

10/10 recommend!

James and Jimmie kill it in every podcast they do. STM is always at the top of my list and is very entertaining.

Great show to help pass the day at work

Here we are.

Love you guys! There were a couple toes over your line of not being scum bags. Even tho speaking as Dana, name calling of the sister at the end of this episode. Just wanted to point that out.

I love these guys /

I came across this podcast about a year ago & listen to this every day while I work. You guys crack me up!!

Love them

Perfect combination of true crime and comedy. Italian grandmothers forever! I’m sure the ravioli was fab!

Love your podcast. You guys keep me going while at work. Keep ‘em coming.

Forever my favorite podcast

I especially liked the episode where the town burned down sometime between 1803-1926.

Love it! These guys are the absolute best. They somehow mix humor and murder in a wonderful way.

Very very slay. Even better live!

Love you guys!! Been listening since Ep 34 🥰lots of life has happened since then but I hope to come to another live show one day!!

I love the combination of these 2. They paint a full picture of the setting and present cases with respect and proper condemnation of behavior. They examine law enforcement and present mistakes and wins with accuracy. I am a binge listener during road trips. As a solo female traveler I appreciate the humor found in human behavior and I appreciate the commitment to exploring all aspects of a case. Kudos to James and Jimmy!

If I could give more stars i would!!!!

This is the perfect blend of comedy and true crime!

I love this podcast. James and Jimmie are very funny, which seems like a bonkers thing to remark about a true crime podcast, but they trash talk the killer in such a way that is so satisfying. They are also very sensitive in regard to the victims, which is impressive considering they’re 2 bros. I love Jimmie’s genuine (and again comedic) reaction to James’ very detailed tale of murder. Such a good amount of detail, I am always riveted.

Subject matter may be unsettling but no one tells it better! I have had to pull over when listening while driving, I was laughing too hard to see the road! You’re both adorable, stop knocking yourself Jimmie!!

Favorite podcast out there!

The best podcast out there! Can’t go a day without out listening to my Jimmie’s!

Comedy and true crime. This is my fav show.

I have been listening to many podcasts, I can’t get enough of the way you guys give us a load of true crime. I’ve seen you guys in a live show in Dallas. So worth it.

James and Jimmie are hilarious and a perfect yin and yang to each other. Love the cases they pick, the research, and their camaraderie. Love, a southerner listener who is nice and NOT Baptist 🤍

Thankful to hear how stupid people can be so I feel better about myself.

Keep up the great work I listen whenever I’m driving