I used to love this show. Some of the funniest, most insightful hockey writers around. Then they brought up David Volek…

Solid takes with great insight into how the NHL operates.

Sean and Ryan are fantastic. Funny, smart, informative. I would trade all other hockey podcasts for this one. Keep it up!!

These 2 guys are smart hockey guys. But by the time their weekly pod is released all the news is old. Plus they think that if players are not McDavid or McKinnon and a small handful of others, the players all stink at hockey. Just a lot of obnoxious tone with a smarmy attitude that everyone else is stupid except the two of us. Lambert especially. And for 2 guys allegedly in the know, in their most recent pod they wonder why the Islanders picked up 2 defensemen without having a clue that 3/6 of the starting D are hurt. So much for smart hockey guys.

I enjoy this podcast tremendously with one glaring exception. Ryan Lambert’s audio makes it sound like he’s talking on his cell phone and it detracts greatly from the overall quality of the podcast. Ryan, you can buy a great microphone for 100 bucks. Do your fans a favor and invest in one!

I listen to a few hockey podcasts and this is my favorite. Sean and Ryan have a consistently amusing banter without it being the forced “drive time sports guy” affectations. They have takes, sure, but I’ve agreed with most of them. My only complaint would be I’d like it to be more frequent!

These guys used to be so fun and so smart and well-respected. Watching their descent into the most miserable journalists in the business has been heart breaking. I don’t understand why anyone would waste their time with this show when there’s 100 other podcasts by people that actually enjoy the sport.

When the guy you suffer through so you can listen to the guy you like says gems like, “perception is reality” is it time to mash the unsubscribe button? Now the guy you suffer through can’t stop saying, “you know what I mean?” Dude your thought are not so profound that they can’t be followed. Can’t take it anymore. I’ll just listen to the guy I want to on The Athletic pod. Be good gents, you know what I mean?

Been listening since the start, through all the ebbs and flows and host changes. Always good for a laugh and some hockey news. The recent theme music change has absolutely shaken me to my core, but the new one is a banger.

Ryan and Sean are the best. New music intro is VERY appreciated. Love the hockey trivia games they play. Better than the HHOF for sure. Good rooting interest contrasts to NHL developments as Sean is TOR/Canada, Ryan is BOS/college hockey and Greg is NJD/US national headline flavor of the month.

Old one is fantastic. If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

I had to write a review after seeing how many blowhards get mad at Sean and Ryan for not drinking every ounce of NHL kool-aid. Hockey fans are so soft (and just as dumb as Lambert claims). The pod has continued being great with this iteration, it’s too bad there’s so many Don Cherry lover boys that don’t get the joke. Keep it up boys.

This latest episode, Ryan surprised us with the RETURN OF NATURAL TRANSITION ADD READS! I’m so happy I almost swerved off the road and had to stop. I’ve been listening to this show since 2016 and like a real JERK I have never given a rating or review (was a patron until I forgot my password and my credit card expired) BUT NOW! I HAD TO! Thank you for the Post-Draft Gift Ryan and Sean! The fans have been deprived for TOO LONG! ❤️

I don’t usually write negative reviews, but this podcast has gotten too lousy, and I had to stop listening because of the hosts. They complain about the NHL way too much, and have such negative views about the league. Guys, that league is why you have a job. They use the same, tired old jokes every episode, and basically just repeat news that they’ve already heard on more legitimate podcasts. Unfortunately the one saving grace to the podcast was Greg, he was actually funny and excitable, but he hasn’t been on the podcast for a while now.

These guys stated Yzerman is overrated in an episode just a few weeks ago. That alone should lose you all credibility. Their opinions come off as know it alls and state it as the absolute truth. Especially homie whose voice sounds like he hiked his pants to his belly button in middle school and played computer games all day.

Love the show, always 5 stars

But they should consider bring Greg back. Assuming this is where I should take this up.

This is the podcast for hockey fans that are tired of the same useless optimism and rose-colored glasses that dominate dumber fans’ bleacher report feeds. If you love the game and love thinking about it realistically, this is the voice of reason you’ve been begging for. Also, subscribe to the Patreon. It’s worth every penny. Honestly, we’re ripping them off.

This is the only hockey podcast I listen to and the only one I need. Informed and humorous, this podcast is helping reignite my love of the sport.

They hate the pervasive sports gambling ads and their intentionally addictive nature. Best hockey podcast very good hockey podcast. Go Coyotes and Caps!

Luckily with my job I am able to listen to hockey and or football podcasts while I am working daily. I’ve given ever major pod for both sports a shot at some point. I will say Puck Soup is a must listen if you are a hockey fan. Love that they are a little snarky to the league and certain teams at times, usually well deserved. But also give respect to players and teams when deserved. - love these guys!

I love every version of it. I miss Lozo and I miss Wyshynski, but Ryan and Sean are doing a great job and Puck Soup is as good as ever. Somewhat similar to the Biscuit podcast with Sean and Lozo which was great as well. Sean and Ryan, it’s about time you reflect upon the Sedins’ career!

Updated review as of 8/28/2022: Still my fav podcast hands down. I started listening during Puck Soup 2.0 (RL, SM & GW) and love it even more as Puck Soup 3.0 (sans GW) which loosened the structure a lot in a positive way. I also subscribe to their top tier Patreon page as well for additional content, which is usually is good. No interest in the wrestling crap, GW articles, Mise en pod, Discord stuff, but the other content is usually fun and super entertaining. Original review: Appointment listening for me. Great hosts, especially Sean and Ryan, each bringing something different to the table and complimenting each other. Any chance you guys can make your pods a bit longer? 90 mins is too short in my opinion

I've listened for years and I'll keep going as long as they keep making them, regardless of the lineup. Their Patreon is also the only one I subscribe to. Every episode, both on the main feed and the Patreon, splits the difference between "rigidly structured" and "morons flying by the seat of their pants" in a way that is both a consistently great hang and full of good info presented in a compelling way.

After 6 years of faithful listening, I’m out. Sean is great and I really enjoy his podcast with Ian Mendes but Lambert is insufferable, especially now that Greg is gone. He runs with the same overplayed schtick every podcast. Just painful!!

Love these guys, my favorite hockey podcast. Don’t take themselves too seriously and are honest about the sport, both the positives and the negatives.

Been looking for a new podcast but these guys are on the softer side. They lost me when they said how there shouldn’t be hitting in the sport

More wrestling than hockey and I don’t care about wrestling.

Love this podcast. It’s become my favorite one since Greg left.

Since Greg left to write his ESPN puff pieces about McDavid, Crosby, and Ovechkin, here's a summary of the show: Sticks and hits and goals and saves and slapshots and goons... Lambert: THAT RAWKS McIndoe: Mumbling Lambert: THAT RAWKS McIndoe: Mumbling Break for a very awkwardly read Manscaped ad Lambert: THAT RAWKS McIndoe: Mumbling Lambert: THAT RAWKS McIndoe: Mumbling We're your weekly bowl of hockey in that sense, Puck Soup

First time long time. MVSW was great. Puck Soup 1.0 was brilliant. This version of Puck Soup isn’t quite as funny but Greg and Sean carry the show whilst Lambert complains about everything. Still the best hockey podcast.

I normally do not enjoy hockey podcasts that go into pop culture segments and if you hadn't mentioned Simple Pages when discussing Weezer’s Green Album you would have lost me. But alas, you have that great song it’s due. Oh and you also did a great job breaking down win totals for the season. Keep up the great work.

Ryan Lambert is a top 3 Puck Soup host

My favorite hockey podcast hands down, the best, look forward to it every week, I even save it so i can take my time and enjoy it uninterrupted on the weekend, pair with some coffee and a dutch? Chef’s kiss reference! Thanks!

Greg, Ryan, and Sean are a fantastic trio! Every episode is entertaining and insightful as they dive into the world of the NHL.

High minded narcissistic people who think they’re smarter than everyone. Hypocrites who attack people for their political views. Leave politics out of the show and stick to hockey.

These guys are experts in East coast hockey.. but keep your Dallas and San Jose opinions to yourself. Saying Heiskanen is overrated ruins all credibility. Also to the guy cursing every 5 words, it’s not cool anymore. We’re grown ups

Why is this the only podcast where you can hear typing all the time in the background? Very annoying and makes it unlistenable sometimes, but not as annoying as Ryan Lambert, who is always snarky and negative. He thinks he knows everything and all hockey teams are idiots. All three of the host do lean on the negative side of things and makes you wonder why they even watch NHL games.

And would give a podcast of just those two 5/5. Been listening to Greg since the MvsW days, ESPN Greg is beyond terrible. Dumb arguments, narrative chasing, straw man, and crap analysis.

Two snarky, pompous hosts that think they’re smarter than everyone else and are essentially the same person so they argue all the time and one level-headed guy that keeps the podcast going. Probably the best hockey podcast out there.

This podcast makes me laugh at work every Wednesday I only have one problem with it....too much islander hate baby! Go isles #mattymartin

Man Ryan calling Shaq and Chuck secondary NBA stars is blasphemous. Shaq is top 10 greatest NBA players OF ALL TIME and the round mound of rebound is in top 50. Bad example Lambert bad, bad Lambert

I just discovered this and it’s freaking great. Tons of good hockey talk. Smart but funny, way better than sport talk radio. Way better than a lot of fan pods. And fun pop culture talk too.

Wyshynski knows his stuff, but can do better than his clout-chasing partners.

Constant dumb takes from one of the cohosts begging for attention

This is the first time I have ever felt compelled to write a podcast review. Love this show and the nuanced intelligent takes the hosts have. It also often makes me laugh out loud and the only podcast I listen to right when it come out. Love this pod and would highly recommend it!

As a hockey fan, Puck Soup is a great balance of fun and information. I look forward to a new episode each week.

This is definitely the Hockey podcast to listen to if you’re a nerd and like the sport. It’s informative and has some great tangents. I don’t agree with their Overrated, Underrated, Favorite and Least Favorite Zelda items, but they are still great.

Besides being a bit long (podcasts should be no longer than 45 minutes) the frequent f-bombs, by Greg especially, just doesn’t go over well. It detracts from credibility. It doesn’t make them more relatable. Too bad because Greg and Sean are really good. By the way, this is not Mark Scheifele!

Among the many hockey podcasts, I believe this one has to be the funniest. They have a great set of hosts that consistently provide quality content and good humor. Keep up the great work!