I was gearing up to pull the trigger on the Patreon, and then listened to the last Traitors podcast preview. Oh my lanta - Evan says he’s done with the show after a good episode and that Sean is Carolyn-pilled? It doesn’t make for a good listen. I was ok with the Survivor hate because, New Era deserves it. But now I think it’s just an Evan problem. He’s leading with attitude & not insight, with Sean doing his best to salvage it. Give our baby a break!

Evan and Sean have great banter, commentary, and knowledge. They aren’t afraid to give their opinions and perspectives. Refreshing to hear that level of candor.

Love listening to their banter no matter the topic!

I look forward to listening to Sean and Evan every week! Far and away, this is my favorite pod I subscribe to. They really make me feel like I’m just kiki’ing and vibing with them. Admittedly, they don’t just talk about the shows they’re recapping, but that’s exactly what I love about them!! They help me stay in tune with pop culture, other shows I might like. They make me laugh the whole time, from talking about their lives to playing Star or Starless. They’re honest and they actually critique the shows they watch. As a certified hater through-and-through, these are my people. You don’t just have to love all the content you consume… and they get that. Their instagram is so entertaining and their Patreon is so worth the money. 10/10 pod for me and always recommending it to my friends. You guys are my faves. Keep doing what you’re doing!

From Buffy to Survivor to White Lotus, Evan and Sean are currently recapping the latest season of US Traitors, and as a Patreon member, I am fed, I have eaten, and I am satisfied.

Last year, I migrated over as a ShutUpEvan fan for coverage of Traitors US Season 2, but equally fell in love Sean. I love hearing all of Evan and Sean’s takes, repartee, and memes.

Insightful, hilarious, and so much fun— this podcast breaks down the shows we watch in an honest and joyous way. Hallelujah. -IR

Great show.. don’t need a voice memo but need you to talk about my idea for the traitors where the reward for a challenge is a riddle that gives a hint at the identity of a traitor. Would be fun bc traitors would want to sabotage and riddles would be theatrical and balance the playing field.

I have been a Buffy from the beginning and absolutely love the pod. I look forward to every episode and Patreon drop and I appreciate that they cover more than just Survivor. Episodes where they are super invested in the show tend to be my favorites, and find the differing perspective of most Probst disciples refreshing! If you are new to the pod, I suggest dipping your toes in with a rewatch, interview, traitors recap, AJLT, tree mail bag or postmortem episode to fully appreciate these two at their best. I could listen to Evan and Sean talk about anything, their chemistry and humor is perfection. A true standout in my podcast lineup.

I can’t wait for when S48 and what reason they have to not take break. I love the pod, I love the way they banter and talk about anything in entertainment. But season after season lately it’s just been so exhausting to listen to. And they seem over it too. Hope they find some new life with Traitors 3 or And Just Like That or something because I need anything different.

A survivor podcast that hates survivor.

Terrible once they actually get around to talking about something other than their semi charmed lives. Get some self awareness about how you present yourselves. It’s not a good look. Mean girls for sure.

From a quality commentary standpoint, Sean and Evan have always had a fresh perspective on the show; keeping it smart and witty. However, what makes me not appreciate it so much anymore is that the negativity has overtaken the show. Evan seems to absolutely hate the current version of the show, being dismissive about almost anything that happens, and often does not seem interested in talking about survivor and goes in tangents about other pop culture stuff. He often does not even know the names of the players!! If you are still somewhat excited, this may hinder your experience as a fan. At times I often end up skipping the episode. I wonder if Sean should find a new cohost, someone that is interested in the current seasons of Survivor and actually watches them.

When they actually talk about Survivor, sure. But there’s so much other nonsense to wade through, like Evan’s travel schedule & how busy he is. Maybe it’s time for Sean to find a new co-host who actually wants to be there & isn’t “threatening” to leave all the time. GURL. It’s so off-putting & narcissistic & big head crazypants.

this is my favorite Survivor pod and they post great content on Instagram too. BUT they keep posting spoilers on Instagram - last two episodes have been spoiled for me because of their grid posts…sigh, have to unfollow. catch you on the pod only, Sean and Evan.

I went looking for a new Survivor Pod to listen to. It's been 14 minutes (episode with Sophie Clarke) and they're still not talking about the episode! I'm out.

Within 10 minutes of listening I realized this was not a podcast for me. Too much complaining labeled as critiquing. I just don’t understand how you claim to love the show. Too each his own I guess.

This podcast is amazing for Survivor fans who love to hate the show because clearly there is nothing to love about the “New Era” and Jeff Probst’s decisions as an EP.

I mean, they bullied Ben. (Season46) but that’s like really mean he was one of my fav players.🫤😢 would NOT recommend

This podcast thinks they’re witty, but they’re just a toxic bullies. Specifically, they said Ben doesn’t have much going on between his ears and laughed at him. You literally bullied the guy where it’s part of his story that he was bullied when he was younger. Also, their episode with Carolyne was so cringe and unlistenable. Would not recommend.

Finally unsubscribing. There are so many better Survivor pods that offer both humor and critique. This one is straight up hours of complaining. Yawn.

However, i have been feeling lately like those who are not willing to pay for the patreon are getting nothing. i feel like interviews would be nice, and maybe a rewatch of a more popular season would be nice on the main feed, something like cambodia or david vs goliath. it’s definitely not you’re fault that 46 is giving nothing, but i feel like the podcast for the main feed has been, like survivor, feeling redundant.

I’ve been listening since S42 and this week was when I finally decided that I’m out. The problems are self evident and I’m not going to use this space to drag the podcast. I am however, leaving a one-star rating because well, the podcast is starless.

As a new listener and fellow member of the alphabet gang, I feel like I have a love-hate relationship with this podcast! While I genuinely appreciate Shawn and Evans’ critiques and analysis of the show from a production standpoint, the negativity about the show itself and specially how season 46 is unfolding is quite tough to listen to. I totally understand and agree with many of the production critiques they have mentioned of 46 / new era, and I know Sean and Evan verbatim said beginning of this season said they weren’t interested in covering the particular season but are still doing it anyway…. But I almost feel like it would be better if they didn’t because the energy feels a lil jaded (I say that with love here)! For example the whole thing about hunter in the latest could have just been edited out if we weren’t gonna get to hear your perspectives. Like I would much rather hear hunter analysis than hear y’all objectifying Bhanu??? That felt weird. I first found this podcast through folks mentioning on reddit and then listening to the interviews with previous survivor legends like Parvati and Sandra, and I really found those shows a lot more exciting and awesome. Maybe it would help to get more ex castaways to join the show for the recaps so they could share their thoughts and mix up the energy a bit. Anyway will keep listening in hopes that things can improve

Look folks, this is not an ego stroking podcast to Survivor’s production team. This is a podcast coming from two diehard fans of the show. The show has cast brilliantly over the years; unfortunately, Survivor 46 is no where near the compelling storytelling the show once was. If you are a new era Survivor apologist, this podcast is not for you. This recap show is for those that appreciate honest conversations, dissecting what contributes to great television (not just great strategy). I value entertainment analysis vs strictly strategy analysis, which is why I tune in. Very gay and very honest - thank you!

Listen, I gave some constructive criticism with my 5star review back in the day, but now I’m a Patreon subscriber. In my unsolicited opinion, they’ve gotten a lot better at critiquing the show. I have my own criticisms with the show and honestly how can you not have a bunch of criticisms for Survivor?? I do however agree with the last review— the spoilers hurt my feelings. Like just because you saw a spoiler for the Traitors finale, you don’t have to share that— save it for after the episode airs and tell us that you were spoiled. Same thing happened for me with the Kate reveal. BUT to be fair, I understand that the hosts and a lot of the people who listen are very online and I’m the one who is different. So maybe that’s my problem. I still wouldn’t stop listening.

I have been a fan for the last year or so and finally subscribed to the Patreon and the timing could not have been better because of Evan and Sean’s excellent coverage of the Traitors US, old season recaps, and deep dives into the ongoing disappointment that is New Era Survivor. Their honesty keeps me grounded in a world where New Era Survivor is trying beat me into submission. Sorry to those who don’t want historicism and reality with their reality tv, but this podcast only keeps getting better!

Unlike Jeff Probst, Sean and Evan just get it. I have been a DYB listener and patron since the very beginning. Every week, the one thing I look forward to most is this pod to hear their takes which some may think are unpopular but are actually just the truth. Listeners are fed with a variety of shows and to be frank, I’m stuffed. Stars all around, no other notes!

The negativity is tough, but I keep listening hoping you guys will turn a corner! I didn’t want to mess up your reviews with anything but 5 stars, but there really should be spoiler warnings.. several things on traitors were spoiled for me (because I’m not watching the previews with hawk eyes and don’t know the chronology of each challenge) and I started the Nicaragua rewatch because I wanted to actually watch the season for the first time and listen along, but then in the first episode you guys said who won and I didn’t know, so I didn’t end up watching the season or listening to the recap. I wish there had been a warning that you guys’ understanding was all listeners have watched all seasons. I hope you guys will keep recapping current seasons but also it does feel like you both genuinely hate it at this point, so maybe stopping isn’t the worst idea. Wanted to share these thoughts without messing up your rating so still giving 5 stars but please stop with the spoilers!!! 😭

Finally unsubscribing — the negativity has become unbearable! If I’m choosing to watch a show, why would I want to listen to the hate every week (and it’s not nuanced cultural criticism)

Love the pod

Found them during survivor. Love the podcast! Listening free episode for traitors 2 and they gave away spoilers for other Traitors shows (uk?) that I haven’t watched yet and planned on watching. So I had to stop immediately.

I found DYB during the summer when I just moved and started a new job with a long commute so I started to listen to the podcast in my car and QUICKLY flew through their episodes! I am not a huge fan of the new era, but I would always make sure to catch up with Sean and Evan every time they posted a new episode review! They even made me a Traitors fan when my mom couldn’t. I was super into 44 and 45 and following Sean and Evan through the journey of these two new era seasons was such a trip! They make their viewers feel seen, always answers questions thoughtfully, offers their own takes and opinions and are truly their authentic selves 100% of the time. It was a rough 2023 for me and there is just something about this podcast that’s truly comforting! I love you guys and appreciate all the work you guys do!

4.5 average rating is CRIMINAL. Sean and Evan have the best podcast out there offering a queer, relevant, insightful look at survivor episodes and now other shows I love as well - can’t wait for the Traitors commentary! AND they invite their audience to participate with voice notes, so I totally bragged to all my friends when mine was featured in an episode LOL. LISTEN TO THIS PODCAST!

I have been listening to DYB since the beginning. I have to toot my own horn and say that I knew Sean and Evan’s pod would grow to STAR status because these two are just the best. They feed what I have discovered to be a not-so-small niche of Survivor-obsessed girls gays and theys, and we eat well every week. It’s like if Las Cultch and Know-It-Alls had a baby…and the baby makes itself laugh, invents idioms that are just slightly off from actual idioms, and actively stirs up drama with current players. I earnestly think this pod is breathing new life into the Survivor fandom and for that we should all be grateful. Love!

Wanted to like this…. The whiny co-host obsessed with nonsense details…. Nope.

I joined the patreon solely to see drama on the insta stories.

These gays misremember facts about past seasons constantly and make fun of the contestants, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. If I wanted someone to be nice I would listen to J*ff.

Far and away my favorite podcast let alone survivor podcast. Evan and Sean bring the perspective and nuance that can be lost on the mainstream feeds and fans. Between the two of them there’s a balanced perspective - groundbreaking- which I guess is increasingly unfamiliar in these polarizing times. They also center women and POC, understand the cultural and power dynamics at play in the game and outside of it, and are body and sex positive and it’s all just like an oasis in the middle of a desert of dude bro macho game bot survivor takes. WHILE BEING HILARIOUS THO. I love their little and big takes- from the cinematography and editing of a challenge to the real realness about their views of players. They’re friends with the best survivor legends but also simultaneously not afraid to read players to filth. It’s like part gossip magazine part art critique with these two and I live for it. Highlights are when they laugh uncontrollably together and make fun of Jeff’s obsolescence. After a while you’ll be watching Survivor and something will be said and you’ll be like “oop that’s gunna be on the pod.” It’s also a Parvati fan club in here which tells you all you need to know about ideological alignment. Proud Patreon- the only podcast I pay for, and happily, for as long as they’ll make content. Thanks guys for all your hard work.

ILY Evan and Sean!!!!! Honestly not enough poison in my opinion!!! More poison!

Survivor continues to get floppier every season, but I watch anyway so I can listen to the Drop Your Buffs recaps. Sean and Evan make me laugh so hard. I love poison!

Like some other listeners I am also a bit addicted, at least to the Survivor content. I think Sean and Evan balance each other out well. It’s kind of funny and kind of concerning that both hosts seem to only be doing the podcast out of obligation to some unknown entity — because they don’t like new era survivor, don’t like CBS, definitely have other ventures and interests, and “wouldn’t watch the season except for the podcast”. Secretly they must enjoy it. Survivor is simply the vehicle

Back in January, I started a new job requiring me to drive and alas, my train binge-watching needed a replacement that left my eyes on the road… Enter podcasts about my reality TV guilty pleasures... I tried several survivor pods, most of which I couldn’t get past the first few minutes. Enter Sean & Evan, whose real friendship is evident through their chemistry. Their humor and storytelling make me giggle every week, and for that, I’m thankful. When the season is on hiatus, the rewatches on Patreon are delightful. If you are bothered by criticism of the show, perhaps get out a bit more, try another, more overproduced pod, or find the antidote for poison.

DYB brings me joy, answers questions on why moves were made, and celebrates the wildest, funniest moments of eps. Standard definition seasons were best, get off Evans back everyone!

I was the fan Evan “attacked” on the pod’s and was amused and laughed out loud. Keep up the Survivor coverage and gay on gay crime. If we agreed on everything I wouldn’t keep tuning in ✌🏽

stars all around!

Evan is now attacking fans on the drop your buffs insta! Not a good look…

I loved the earlier seasons but am frustrated how they moved so much honesty hour commentary to the after show & now the main is more strategy analysis. Patreon/ subscriber benefits should be bonus content like the rewatches not the og content now put behind paywall. :)))))) Their audience has grown & they are more enmeshed in the survivor establishment than perhaps they’d like to admit. Can’t have yr cake and eat it too! I’ll be tuning in for Australian recaps tho w/ Sean and Ricard.

Shawn is great, but Evan is so negative that he completely ruins the pod. He clearly doesn’t like the show and I’m not sure why he even does a survivor podcast.

One host is a level headed fan with fair criticisms of missteps or suggestions for tweaks, but who is ultimately here to have a good time with the segments and recaps, and the other is just a hater at this point 😂 hardly ever thinks people are standing out, they are spending so much time each episode nitpicking silly details for not living up to their personal expectations, instead of taking it for what it is, and it’s becoming a drag. :/